# The Offer Room

Real offer situations from Craig Johnston's files, with what he advised and what happened. Updated November 21, 2026.

## 1. Seven offers, and it's December. (Seller)

Your home drew seven offers. You told me two things mattered most: your price, and no offer that depends on the buyer selling their own home first. None of the seven gives you both. It's the middle of December.

Options:
- Take the best of the seven
- Counter the highest and ask them to drop the subject to sale
- Take the home off for the holidays, keep the buyers warm, relist in January

**What I advised:** Take the home off for the holidays, keep the buyers warm, relist in January

Seven offers told us the price was right and the demand was real. What was missing was the right buyer on the right terms, and December is when the fewest buyers are looking. Over the holidays I usually take an occupied listing off the market, then keep talking to every agent whose buyers were interested so they're ready to move in January.

The trade-offs:
- Take the best of the seven: Done before the holidays, but it means giving up one of your two priorities.
- Counter the highest and ask them to drop the subject to sale: Worth trying, but a buyer who has to sell first often can't simply remove that condition.

**What happened:** Relisted in January, it sold in three days at the seller's target price, with no subject to sale.

> "We received seven offers, and Craig held firm on our priorities: no subject to sale and achieving our price." — Jim Turnbull, seller · Google review

## 2. One offer on the table. (Seller)

An offer arrives. Several other buyers have been through the home, but none of them has written yet.

Options:
- Accept it
- Counter this buyer and only this buyer
- Tell every agent whose buyers have seen the home that an offer is in

**What I advised:** Tell every agent whose buyers have seen the home that an offer is in

Leverage comes from competition. A buyer who was on the fence will often write once they know someone else has. I go back to every agent whose client has seen the home before we answer the first offer.

The trade-offs:
- Accept it: Certain and quick. But you'll never know what the other buyers would have done.
- Counter this buyer and only this buyer: Can move the price a little. It's still one buyer negotiating against no one.

**What happened:** Soon there were multiple offers, all over the asking price.

> "After receiving one offer, he quickly reconnected with all the other realtors who had viewed the property, and before I knew it, we had multiple offers—all over asking price!" — Heather Fox, seller · Google review

## 3. Your buyer's financing just fell through. (Seller)

A busy launch, multiple offers, and a sale the next day. Then the buyer can't get their financing, and the deal collapses.

Options:
- Relist next week and start the launch over
- Lower the price to win buyers back
- Call back the buyers who already offered, today

**What I advised:** Call back the buyers who already offered, today

The buyers who lost out in the first round were the warmest buyers in the market. A collapsed deal isn't a problem with the home, and I don't want the market to read it as one. I went straight back to the agents who had written offers.

The trade-offs:
- Relist next week and start the launch over: A clean restart, but the momentum from launch week is gone.
- Lower the price to win buyers back: Brings attention, but tells the market something is wrong when nothing is.

**What happened:** A new offer came in the next day, with a backup offer behind it. The home sold over the asking price.

## 4. You can't be the highest offer. (Buyer)

You've found the home. You're one of several offers, and you're near the top of your budget. You can't be the highest price.

Options:
- Stretch the budget anyway
- Write your best price and hope
- Build the offer around what the seller needs, at a price close to the top

**What I advised:** Build the offer around what the seller needs, at a price close to the top

Winning isn't always about the highest price, but you have to be close. Before writing, I call the listing agent, ask the right questions and listen for what the sellers need: often a completion date that lines up with their next home. Then I build an offer the listing agent can show their sellers as the best one on the table.

The trade-offs:
- Stretch the budget anyway: Sometimes possible, but it's how buyers end up regretting the payment.
- Write your best price and hope: Fine if you're the highest. Here, you probably aren't.

**What happened:** I've won for buyers on dates when we weren't the highest price.

Every sale is different, and past results don't guarantee future outcomes.

## Common questions about offers

### Should I accept the first offer on my home?

Not automatically, and not automatically reject it either. First check who else has seen the home and tell their agents an offer is in. Then compare every offer as the money you'd keep, with its subjects, deposit and dates, not just the headline price.

### What is a subject-to-sale offer?

An offer that depends on the buyer selling their current home first. It's common for move-up buyers, but it leaves the seller waiting on a sale they don't control. A seller can still accept one, often with a clause that lets them keep marketing the home. Talk through the terms with your REALTOR® and lawyer before agreeing.

### What happens if a buyer's financing falls through?

If the buyer can't remove a financing subject by the deadline, the contract usually ends and the home is available again. How the deposit is handled depends on the contract's wording, so ask your REALTOR® and lawyer. The fastest recovery is usually going back to the buyers who were already interested.

### Is the highest offer always the best one?

No. A slightly lower offer with fewer subjects, a larger deposit and dates that fit your next move can be worth more and is often more likely to close. Compare offers by what you'd net and how likely each is to complete.

Craig Johnston, REALTOR® (BCFSA Licence #187645), Craig Johnston Personal Real Estate Corporation, Royal LePage Elite West.
