Sold by Craig
Blog
Home Value Call Craig

November 18, 2026 · BC Property Owner Guide · Part 2 of 3

Did the Supreme Court of Canada Rule on Aboriginal Title and Private Property?

In May 2026, headlines said Canada's top court had decided Aboriginal title can't apply to private land. It didn't. Here's what New Brunswick's Wolastoqey case actually decided, why it disagrees with BC's Cowichan ruling, and how the question is likely to get settled.

Quick Answer

No, the Supreme Court of Canada has not ruled on it. On May 28, 2026, it declined to hear an appeal from New Brunswick, without reasons, as is normal. That leaves the New Brunswick Court of Appeal's decision final in New Brunswick only. That court held a declaration of Aboriginal title isn't available over private land when the owners aren't in the case, and pointed to compensation from the Crown instead. BC's Cowichan trial decision went the other way. The conflict will most likely be settled through the Cowichan appeal, with hearings scheduled to begin in November 2027.

Key takeaways

Before we start

I'm a REALTOR®, not a lawyer. This is general information to help you follow a legal story. It isn't legal advice or a comment on the merits of any Nation's claim. For a specific property, speak with a BC real estate lawyer. Aboriginal title is a constitutionally protected right, and this piece is written with respect for that.

This is Part 2 of my series on Aboriginal title and private property. Part 1 covers the Cowichan decision in Richmond, and Part 3 covers the Kwikwetlem claim in Coquitlam and Port Coquitlam.

What happened in New Brunswick

In 2020, six Wolastoqey First Nations sued the Province of New Brunswick and Canada, claiming Aboriginal title to their traditional territory. The claim covers more than 60% of the province. CBC has reported that roughly 253,000 of the 283,000 land parcels in that territory are privately owned.

In 2021 the Nation added several large private landowners to the case, including the forestry companies J.D. Irving, H.J. Crabbe & Sons and Acadian Timber. In November 2024, a Court of King's Bench judge removed those companies as defendants, but left their land in the claim. The companies appealed.

On December 11, 2025, the New Brunswick Court of Appeal ruled in J.D. Irving, Limited et al. v. Wolastoqey Nation, 2025 NBCA 129. In plain language, it decided:

Justice Ernest Drapeau put the court's view simply: in his words, "remedial justice favours compensation from the Crown over dispossession of private fee simple owners."

Sources: 2025 NBCA 129; Fasken, Gowling WLG and Torys analyses; CBC News (linked below).

What the Supreme Court of Canada did, and didn't, decide

The Wolastoqey Nation asked the Supreme Court of Canada for permission to appeal (Supreme Court docket 42204). On May 28, 2026, the court said no, without reasons. That's standard: it gives reasons for almost none of its leave decisions.

What the May 28, 2026 decision means
It does meanIt does not mean
The New Brunswick Court of Appeal decision is final in New BrunswickThe Supreme Court of Canada agreed with it
BC lawyers can cite it in the Cowichan appealBC courts have to follow it
The national question is still openAboriginal title "can't apply to private land" across Canada

Why might the court have declined? Commentators point to one likely reason: Wolastoqey was a pre-trial decision with no evidence heard yet. The Cowichan Nation, which asked to intervene, argued the question should be decided on a full trial record. Cowichan has exactly that. The court didn't say, so treat this as informed commentary, not fact.

The federal government said afterward that "private property rights are fundamental," and that it will make every legally viable argument to protect private property in the Cowichan appeal.

Why BC and New Brunswick disagree

Two courts, two answers
BC: Cowichan (2025 BCSC 1490)New Brunswick: Wolastoqey (2025 NBCA 129)
Court levelTrial courtCourt of Appeal
StageAfter a 513-day trialPre-trial, before any evidence
Land involvedAbout 300 hectares in south RichmondMore than 60% of New Brunswick
Private landTitle declared over an area that includes it; the two titles "coexist"No declaration over private land when owners aren't parties
Private titles cancelled?No; only some government titlesNo
Remedy for private landProvince must negotiate a reconciliationCompensation from the Crown
StatusUnder appeal; hearings from November 2027Final in New Brunswick

The heart of the disagreement is what happens when Aboriginal title and private ownership land on the same ground. The BC trial judge said both can exist at once, with Aboriginal title as the "prior and senior" right. The New Brunswick court said a court can't make that declaration over private land without the owners in the case, and that governments should pay instead.

Is compensation the answer?

New Brunswick's approach is essentially this: the owner keeps the land, and if title is proven, the government that sold it pays. Supporters say it respects both sides. Private owners who bought in good faith keep their homes, and the First Nation is compensated for a real loss.

There are fair criticisms too. Some legal scholars argue a "finding" without a declaration leaves the Nation with money instead of land, which isn't what many Nations are seeking. And compensation is paid by governments, which ultimately means taxpayers. How much, and which government pays, is unsettled.

In BC, the Cowichan court took a different route: it ordered the Province to negotiate how private titles and Cowichan title fit together. BC and the Cowichan began those negotiations on March 2, 2026. Both have said publicly that neither is seeking to invalidate private titles.

How this will likely get settled

  1. BC Court of Appeal stay hearings (January 2027). Six parties are asking the court to pause parts of the Cowichan ruling, which is otherwise due to take full effect in February 2027.
  2. Cowichan appeal hearings (scheduled to begin November 2027). The Crown has asked for a five-judge panel because of how significant the issues are.
  3. A possible Supreme Court of Canada appeal. Whoever loses at the BC Court of Appeal can ask the Supreme Court of Canada to hear it. Nothing is scheduled, and it's likely years away.

There's one other route: the federal government could ask the Supreme Court of Canada a direct question, called a "reference." BC's Conservative leader urged this in 2025. I found no sign that one has been made.

Sources: CBC News and Business Examiner (October 2026); Torys, Blakes and Cassels (May–June 2026); Province of BC (March 2, 2026).

My take as a REALTOR®

Opinion, clearly labelled

This is my personal view as a residential REALTOR® and homeowner, not legal advice.

I was taught, like most people in this business, that a registered fee simple title is as solid as it gets. So the New Brunswick approach makes sense to me. Protect the owner, and if a First Nation proves its title over land the government sold, the government makes it right. Families need to be protected when government makes a mistake, whichever side of the fence they're on.

But the law is the law, and we're all bound by it. What we need now is clarity, and that will come from the courts: the BC Court of Appeal first, and likely the Supreme Court of Canada after it. Until then, I'd ignore headlines that say it's already been decided. It hasn't.

Frequently asked questions

Did the Supreme Court of Canada rule that Aboriginal title can't exist on private land?

No. On May 28, 2026 it declined to hear an appeal of New Brunswick's Wolastoqey decision, without giving reasons. Refusing to hear a case is not a ruling on the legal question. Some headlines said otherwise, and they were wrong.

What did the New Brunswick Court of Appeal decide?

On December 11, 2025, in J.D. Irving, Limited et al. v. Wolastoqey Nation, 2025 NBCA 129, it held that a court can't declare Aboriginal title over privately owned land when the owners aren't part of the case. The Nation can still seek a finding of title, which could support a claim for compensation from the Crown, but not the return of the land.

Is the New Brunswick decision binding in British Columbia?

No. It's final and binding in New Brunswick. BC courts can consider it as persuasive, and BC's lawyers are expected to rely on it in the Cowichan appeal, but BC courts aren't required to follow it.

How is New Brunswick different from the BC Cowichan decision?

Cowichan is a full trial decision that declared Aboriginal title over an area including private land, and said the two kinds of title coexist. Wolastoqey is a pre-trial decision that said a declaration over private land isn't available, and that compensation from the Crown is the remedy.

When will the Supreme Court of Canada decide this question?

Nothing is scheduled. The likeliest route is the Cowichan case, which first has to be decided by the BC Court of Appeal. Appeal hearings are scheduled to begin in November 2027, so a Supreme Court of Canada decision is likely years away.

What does this mean for my home in Coquitlam or elsewhere in BC?

Nothing has changed for your title today. Both cases are about specific land in Richmond and New Brunswick. What's unsettled is the legal principle, which the courts will clarify over the next few years.

Sources & Methodology

Drawn from the court decisions and published legal analysis, current to November 18, 2026:

  1. New Brunswick Court of Appeal — J.D. Irving, Limited et al. v. Wolastoqey Nation, 2025 NBCA 129 (December 11, 2025).
  2. Supreme Court of Canada — docket 42204, leave to appeal dismissed May 28, 2026.
  3. BC Supreme Court — Cowichan Tribes v. Canada (Attorney General), 2025 BCSC 1490 (August 7, 2025).
  4. Torys — Supreme Court of Canada declines to hear Wolastoqey Nation appeal (May 2026).
  5. Blakes — Update: Supreme Court of Canada denies leave to appeal in Wolastoqey Nation (June 2026).
  6. Fasken — New Brunswick Court of Appeal finds Aboriginal title cannot co-exist with fee simple title (January 2026).
  7. Province of BC — statement on BC–Cowichan negotiations (March 2, 2026).
  8. CBC News — reporting on the Wolastoqey claim (2024–2026) and the Cowichan stay applications (October 2026).

Methodology: legal findings are summarized from the decisions and the published analyses above; commentary about why the Supreme Court of Canada declined is labelled as commentary. General information only, not legal advice.

Signed: Craig Johnston, REALTOR® (BCFSA Licence #187645) · Royal LePage Elite West

Have a question about your title or your next move?

Headlines rarely tell the whole story. If you're buying or selling in the Tri-Cities and want a clear, no-pressure read on your specific situation, let's talk it through — and I'll point you to the right lawyer if you need one.

Direct: 604-202-6092 · Craig@SoldByCraig.ca

Craig Johnston, REALTOR® — Earned on a Top 1% Team (2023–2025), 47+ year Tri-Cities resident, 10+ year Burke Mountain resident

About the author

Earned on a Medallion Club Team — Greater Vancouver REALTORS®, 2021–2025

Craig Johnston, REALTOR®

10+ year Burke Mountain resident, 47+ year Tri-Cities native, earned on a Top 1% Team — Greater Vancouver REALTORS®, 2023–2025, earned on a Top 2% Team — Royal LePage nationwide, 2023–2025, earned on a Medallion Club Team, 2021–2025, with Royal LePage Elite West. BCFSA Licence #187645, regulated by the BC Financial Services Authority (BCFSA).

Specializes in Coquitlam, Burke Mountain, Westwood Plateau, Heritage Mountain, Port Moody, Anmore acreage, and Belcarra Indian Arm waterfront. Move-up family representation, first-time buyer guidance, $3M+ luxury.

Full bio + credentials Book a free strategy call

Tri-Cities monthly

One clear read on the Tri-Cities market, monthly.

October 2026 Coquitlam detached HPI is $1,571,400, -7.0% YoY. What that means for your buy or sell decision — without the salesy fluff. One email per month. Unsubscribe anytime.

No spam, no listings flood, no marketing automation games. Genuine monthly update from a 47+ year Tri-Cities resident.

Neighbourhood guides

Local guidance for your specific Tri-Cities city or neighbourhood.

Choosing an agent: questions to ask before you hire a REALTOR® →