Should You Accept a Low Offer on Your Home or Wait for Another Buyer?
For Coquitlam, Port Moody and Port Coquitlam sellers holding an offer that came in below asking. How to tell whether it is really low, what waiting costs, how to counter without losing the buyer, and a real townhouse negotiation from this fall.
Quick Answer
In Coquitlam, Port Moody and Port Coquitlam, judge a "low" offer against recent sold comparables and the homes you're competing with — not your asking price or BC Assessment. If it's close to what similar homes sold for, the terms are clean and waiting costs you every month, a reasoned counter usually beats walking away. If it's well below the solds, counter firmly or let it go.
Holding an offer right now? Book a 20-minute call and send it to me before you respond.
Is this offer actually low, or is my asking price high?
That is the first question, and it is uncomfortable. An offer only feels low against a reference point. The three common reference points are:
- Your asking price. This is a marketing number. It may be right, or it may be a hope.
- Your BC Assessment. It reflects a valuation date in the past and a mass-appraisal model. It is not what a buyer will pay this month.
- Recent sold comparables plus active competition. This is the one that matters. What have similar homes nearby sold for in the last few months, and what is a buyer looking at instead of yours today?
That last one is how I price every listing: sold comparables, then the active listings a buyer is comparing you against, then market direction. If you want the longer version, here is how I price from sold comparables.
Market direction matters this fall. GVR's benchmark price (the MLS® HPI estimate for a typical home — not an average sale price) is down year-over-year for every Tri-Cities property type: Coquitlam detached −7.0%, townhouses −6.6% and condos −9.1% (GVR, October 2026). If your asking price was set from a peak-era comparable, a buyer's "low" offer may simply be today's market talking.
What does the October 2026 market say about my leverage?
Supply is the honest measure of leverage. GVR treats a sales-to-active ratio below about 12% as leaning toward a buyer's market, above about 20% as leaning toward a seller's market, and between those as balanced.
| City | Type | Sales-to-active | Avg days on market |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coquitlam | Detached | 13.2% | 38 |
| Coquitlam | Townhouse | 19.1% | 23 |
| Coquitlam | Condo | 14.3% | 36 |
| Port Moody | Detached | 8.6% | 36 |
| Port Moody | Townhouse | 31.6% | 42 |
| Port Coquitlam | Detached | 12.4% | 46 |
| Port Coquitlam | Townhouse | 31.1% | 16 |
| Port Coquitlam | Condo | 21.3% | 31 |
Source: GVR, October 2026.
What this means in plain terms:
- A Coquitlam detached seller is competing with 425 active listings against 56 sales that month (GVR, October 2026). Buyers have choice, and they know it.
- A Port Coquitlam townhouse seller is in a tighter segment — 61 active against 19 sales (GVR, October 2026). There is more room to hold your number.
- A Port Moody detached seller, at 8.6%, is in buyer's-market territory if that level holds (GVR, October 2026). An engaged buyer is worth more there.
Your micro-market matters more than the city average. A well-presented Burke Mountain townhouse and a dated condo with a special levy coming are not in the same negotiation.
How strong is the offer beyond the price?
Two offers at the same price can be worth very different amounts to you. Before you react to the number, read the terms:
- Deposit. A meaningful deposit shows commitment. Note when it is paid — on acceptance or on subject removal.
- Subjects (conditions). Financing, inspection, strata documents, sale of the buyer's home. Each one is a way the deal might not hold, and the subject period is time your home is effectively off the market. More on subjects and conditions.
- Financing. Has the buyer been pre-approved, and by whom? A financed offer from a well-prepared buyer can be as solid as cash; an unprepared one is not. See cash vs financed offers.
- Completion and possession dates. If you are buying too, dates that line up can be worth more than a few thousand dollars. In a sell-and-buy move, my target is completions within 48 hours of each other.
- Subject to the sale of the buyer's home. This is the weakest kind of offer. It can work, but it needs protective terms.
For me, the biggest signal isn't on the contract at all. It's how the buyer's agent presents the offer. When an agent understands where their buyers are at, shows respect for my sellers and clearly knows the market, I know they've done their homework. That buyer is serious, even if the first number is low. In today's market there's a set of subjects everyone expects, and those are rarely the problem. Knowledge and respect are what decide whether we have a real conversation. Everything else can be worked through.
Remember the rescission period too. Under B.C. law, buyers of most residential property have three business days after the offer is accepted to rescind, and if they do, they pay the seller 0.25% of the offer price. Neither side can waive that right (BCFSA). On a $950,000 sale, that fee is $2,375 — real money, but it does not make you whole if a buyer walks. Here is my guide to B.C.'s home buyer rescission period.
What does waiting for another buyer actually cost?
Waiting is not free. Every month you hold, you pay to own the home while it is for sale. Here is an illustrative example only — your numbers will differ.
Assumptions (illustrative): mortgage balance $600,000 at 4.5% (interest portion only); property tax $4,200 a year; strata fee $450 a month; insurance $100 a month; utilities $250 a month.
| Monthly cost | Amount |
|---|---|
| Mortgage interest ($600,000 × 4.5% ÷ 12) | $2,250 |
| Property tax ($4,200 ÷ 12) | $350 |
| Strata fee | $450 |
| Insurance | $100 |
| Utilities | $250 |
| Total per month | $3,400 |
| Three months of waiting | $10,200 |
So if you turn down an offer that is $10,000 below your number and the next acceptable offer takes three months, you may have spent about the same amount just carrying the home — before any further change in prices.
If you have already bought your next home, you're carrying two properties, so the monthly cost can come close to doubling. That is exactly why sell first or buy first is such an important early decision.
Also look at the money from the other direction: what you actually take home after commission, legal fees and mortgage discharge. See what you actually net.
How should I counter a low offer?
In B.C., if you change anything at all on a buyer's offer, you have rejected it and made a new offer — and you can't go back and accept the original (BCFSA). So a counter is a decision, not a placeholder.
The biggest mistake I see in the first 24 hours is reacting emotionally. A low offer is frustrating, especially after months of keeping your home show-ready. Take a step back, look at what the offer actually says, and let your REALTOR® handle the back-and-forth. That's our job.
Some of my sellers now go a step further. B.C. rules require a listing agent to present every signed offer, unless the seller has given specific written instructions not to present a particular kind of offer (BCFSA). So my sellers can instruct me in writing not to present offers below a price we agree on together. They never have to see an offer they'd find insulting, and their energy goes to the buyers who are serious. Managing that for my clients is part of the job. I've got you.
Here is how I think about it:
Counter on price, terms, or both. If the price is the gap, counter on price. If the price is workable but the terms are weak, you may hold close to their number and tighten the terms — shorter subject period, a larger deposit, dates that suit you.
Give the small wins, hold firm on the big ones. I talk directly with the buyer's agent. I give the small wins and hold firm on price and dates. My aim is to connect with the other agent so that agent tells their clients the same story I'm telling: why this home is worth this number.
Keep the buyer in the conversation. A buyer who opened low is still a buyer who wrote an offer — in a balanced market, that matters. A counter that is clearly reasoned (with the comparables behind it) keeps them engaged. A counter that feels insulted usually ends the conversation.
Know your floor before you start. Every situation is different, but you should walk in knowing the lowest number you'd accept and why.
A real example from this fall
I recently listed a Tri-Cities townhouse. We had just reduced the price by $40,000 to $999,900. That number wasn't a guess: it was where our last accepted offer had landed before it collapsed on financing. My sellers and I had already talked it through, and we planned to take the home off the market for December if it didn't sell. They weren't going to accept much less than that price.
Then a buyer asked whether we'd take $900,000.
- $900,000: We said no, with no counter. A price that's just been reduced to within market range isn't an invitation to take another 10% off.
- $940,000: No again.
- $975,000: Now we had a real conversation. We came down $900, to $999,000. The buyers walked.
- One week later: They came back at $985,000. We countered at $993,500, and they accepted.
The lesson for both sides: when a seller has already reduced to a price that's within the market range, a lowball offer doesn't save the buyer money. It just stalls the conversation, and sellers find it insulting. But when a buyer comes to the table with something reasonable for today's market, deals happen. Ours did, at $993,500.
For the other side of the table, here is how buyers decide how low to go. Reading it can help you see your offer the way the buyer's agent sees it.
When is walking away the better decision?
Sometimes "no" is the right answer. It usually is when:
- The offer is well below recent comparable solds, and the buyer won't move after a reasoned counter.
- The terms carry so much risk (long subjects, subject to sale with no protection, a thin deposit) that the price on paper isn't the price you are likely to get.
- You don't need to sell right now, your carrying costs are manageable, and your home is genuinely competitive in its segment.
- Accepting would leave you below the amount you need to complete your next purchase.
Walking away is a legitimate negotiating outcome — as long as it's based on the comparables, not the asking price. If you're getting showings but no offers at all, that's a different problem: see why a Coquitlam home won't sell and my price reduction strategy.
Should I wait for December or spring 2027?
Be careful with this one. Many buyers step back over the holidays, so there may be fewer people looking in December. In spring, more buyers often return — but so do more sellers, which means more competition for your home. I can't tell you what prices will do by then, and no one can promise that waiting will produce a better offer.
What I can say: Coquitlam detached sales rose from 46 in September to 56 in October while active listings fell from 482 to 425, and condo sales rose from 63 to 82 while actives fell from 628 to 575 (GVR, September and October 2026). That is one month of data, not a trend. The Bank of Canada's next rate decision is December 9, 2026, after the October 28 decision held the policy rate at 2.50% — and that could affect buyers either way.
If you are weighing the timing question generally, see my now or spring 2027 guide. If you have an offer on the table, weigh that offer against your actual carrying costs, not against a hoped-for spring.
Frequently asked questions
Is it rude to counter a lowball offer in Coquitlam?
No. Countering is a normal part of negotiation. What matters is tone and support — a counter backed by recent comparable sales is far more likely to keep the buyer at the table than a flat "no" or a counter at full asking with no explanation.
Can I accept a low offer and keep showing my home for a better one?
Once you accept, you have a binding contract (subject to the buyer's subjects and the rescission period). You can't simply take a better offer later. A properly drafted backup offer is possible, but it must be structured carefully — talk to your REALTOR® and a lawyer before relying on one.
If I counter, can I go back to the buyer's first offer?
No. In B.C., changing anything in a buyer's offer means you have rejected it and made a new offer. If the buyer then walks away, their original offer is gone. That's why you should decide your floor before you counter.
What if the buyer rescinds after I accept?
Buyers of most residential property in B.C. have three business days after acceptance to rescind, and they pay the seller 0.25% of the purchase price if they do. Your home goes back on the market, so it's worth judging how committed a buyer is — deposit, pre-approval, subjects — before accepting.
Should I accept a low offer if I've already bought my next home?
It depends on the gap and your carrying costs. If you are paying for two homes, every month of waiting costs more, so an offer close to the comparables with solid terms deserves serious weight. Work out your monthly carrying cost first, then compare it with the gap between the offer and your number.
Can I tell my REALTOR® not to show me lowball offers?
Yes, but it must be in writing. Under B.C. rules a listing agent has to present every signed offer, unless the seller has given specific written instructions not to present a certain type of offer, such as one below a set price (BCFSA). Agree on that number with your REALTOR® based on the comparables, and put it in writing.
Sources and methodology
Market figures are from Greater Vancouver REALTORS® (GVR) October 2026 REALTOR® Reports and Stats Package for Coquitlam, Port Moody and Port Coquitlam, with September 2026 Coquitlam figures for the month-over-month comparison. "Benchmark price" refers to the MLS® Home Price Index typical-home estimate, not an average or median sale price. The carrying-cost example is illustrative, using the assumptions stated above; it is not a forecast or a quote. Legal points were checked against BCFSA and People's Law School on November 20, 2026. This is general information, not legal, tax or mortgage advice.
- GVR REALTOR® Reports and Stats Package, October 2026 — Coquitlam market report
- BCFSA — Home buyer rescission period: https://www.bcfsa.ca/public-resources/real-estate/buying-home/home-buyer-rescission-period
- BCFSA — Offers: https://bcfsa.ca/public-resources/real-estate/buying-home/offers-sellers
- People's Law School — Understand the contract of purchase and sale: https://www.peopleslawschool.ca/understand-contract-purchase-sale/
- Bank of Canada — policy rate decision October 28, 2026 (2.50%); next decision December 9, 2026
- BCFSA — Offers (presenting offers; written seller instructions): https://www.bcfsa.ca/industry-resources/real-estate-professional-resources/knowledge-base/practice-resources/offers
Last reviewed November 21, 2026.
Signed: Craig Johnston, REALTOR® (BCFSA Licence #187645) · Royal LePage Elite West · Helping Tri-Cities families move up
Got an offer on the table?
Send it to me before you respond. I'll check it against recent sold comparables and your active competition, and walk you through accept, counter or wait on a 20-minute call. No pitch, no spam.
Direct: 604-202-6092 · Craig@SoldByCraig.ca

